We buy, improve, and hold residential rental properties throughout Northern Indiana, with a practical approach and a commitment to the places we serve.
Whether you're considering selling a property, searching for your next home, or learning more about our company, we're glad you're here.
We're a family-owned buyer, not wholesalers. We often buy with tenants in place and aim to keep them. Even if the property needs work, we're happy to take a look.
Looking for a home in Northern Indiana? Contact us for current vacancies and next steps. Availability changes and isn't guaranteed.
Ask About Vacancies →We're a family-owned real estate business focused on responsible ownership, practical improvements, and lasting relationships.
Read Our Story →We buy houses, duplexes, and small multifamily properties in Northern Indiana, with the goal of holding them for the long term.
Prefer email? acquisitions@arshayproperties.com. Our number, (574) 338-3905, is text only. No obligation. Any purchase is subject to inspection, due diligence and a signed written agreement.
Send the address and a few details. No obligation. We'll do our best to reply quickly.
Contact Us About SellingText (574) 338-3905Our number, (574) 338-3905, is text only.
Well-kept homes in Northern Indiana, managed with care. Text or email us with questions or to set up a showing.
310 W Lexington Ave, Unit A, Elkhart, IN 46516
Welcome to your new home. This newly remodeled apartment has vinyl plank floors throughout and a fresh, warm, move-in-ready feel. It's a comfortable, cozy place to land, with off-street parking too. Step outside and you're about a 5–10 minute walk from downtown Elkhart's restaurants and the Lerner Theatre, Central Park and the Riverwalk (Walk Score 78, Very Walkable).
Utilities: tenant pays electric; gas and water billed monthly through Conservice.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 ext. 1 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · View on MBSR · Contact MBSR about this unit
325 Harrison St, Unit B, Elkhart, IN 46516
775 sq ft is a lot of space for a one-bedroom. Freshly painted, with an open floor plan and vinyl plank floors, it gives you room to spread out and make it your own. You're about a 5–10 minute walk from downtown Elkhart, the Lerner Theatre and Central Park, near the bus line (Walk Score 66).
Utilities: tenant pays electric and NIPSCO gas; water billed by MBSR.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 ext. 1 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · View on MBSR · Contact MBSR about this unit
Bond St, Unit 1, La Porte IN
One of three newly renovated, spacious units on Bond St, this 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment has a bright sunroom, new flooring, an updated bath and fresh paint. It will be a warm, fresh place to call home, with downtown La Porte, Clear Lake and everyday shopping all under a mile away (Walk Score 64).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
Bond St, Unit 2, La Porte IN
One of three newly renovated, spacious units, this 2-bedroom home has new flooring and fresh paint for a clean, comfortable start. You'll be under a mile from downtown La Porte and the shores of Clear Lake, with shopping close by (Walk Score 64).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
Bond St, Unit 4, La Porte IN
One of three newly renovated, spacious units, this 2-bedroom home has new flooring, fresh paint, and a new kitchen and bath. Downtown La Porte, Clear Lake and everyday shopping are less than a mile from your door (Walk Score 64).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
Morton Ave, Elkhart IN
Room for the whole family. This two-story, single-family home gives you four bedrooms and 1,570 sq ft to spread out, freshly remodeled with new flooring throughout and fresh paint. It's warm, welcoming and waiting for your family to make it home. Studebaker Park is less than a mile away, with groceries about a mile off. It's getting ready for photos and showings now.
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
N Scott St, South Bend IN
Your new home in South Bend has been fully rehabbed, with a new kitchen, new floors and fresh paint throughout. It's getting its finishing touches now. Leeper Park is less than half a mile away, and downtown South Bend is under a mile (Walk Score 66).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
N Scott St, Unit 1, South Bend IN
A comfortable downstairs home with new vinyl plank floors in the bedrooms, ready for you now. Leeper Park is a short walk away, and downtown South Bend is under a mile (Walk Score 66).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
Harrison St, Unit C, Elkhart IN
Your new home on Harrison St has been freshly remodeled, with new vinyl plank floors throughout, an updated bath, all-new cabinets and fresh paint. It's a 10–15 minute walk to downtown Elkhart and Central Park. Get on the list to hear first when it's ready.
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
W Winona Ave, Unit F, Warsaw IN
Your new home in Warsaw has been freshly remodeled, with a new kitchen, an updated bath, fresh paint and a third bedroom added to give you more room to spread out. You'll be under half a mile from downtown Warsaw's courthouse square, with Central Park and Center Lake within a mile (Walk Score 70).
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
W Winona Ave, Unit G, Warsaw IN
This 3-bedroom home in Warsaw is being remodeled now, with plenty of room to spread out and make it home. It's close to downtown Warsaw's courthouse square, Central Park and Center Lake. Get on the list to hear first when it's ready.
Text or email to get on the interest list.
Managed by MBSR Rentals · (574) 383-5069 · admin@mbsrrentals.com · mbsrrentals.com
Availability and details subject to change; subject to approved application and written lease. Photos are representative and may not reflect current condition. Our number, (574) 338-3905, is text only.
Text or email about the home or area you like.
We'll set up a showing.
We'll send you an application after your tour.
Sign the lease and get your keys.
Current residents: use the contact form for maintenance or rent questions.
Arshay Properties is a family-owned real estate business with a residential portfolio in Northern Indiana. We buy properties, make thoughtful improvements, and hold quality housing for the long term.
We believe in being straightforward, responsive, and committed to the communities where we invest. We work to maintain what we own and to treat the residents who live there well.
Contact UsWe're a hands-on, family-owned company, and we don't do it alone. Our homes are managed day to day by experienced, professional local property managers, and we work with skilled local contractors, handymen and specialists to help keep our homes well cared for.
Experienced local property managers handle leasing, rent and maintenance requests, so residents have a team close by to reach out to.
For remodels and repairs, we bring in skilled contractors, trusted handymen and licensed tradespeople where required.
From inspections to landscaping and other specialty work, we lean on local pros who know Northern Indiana homes.
If you're a property manager, contractor, handyman or specialist based in Northern Indiana and want to be considered to work with us, send us a note.
Submitting doesn't guarantee work; we'll reach out if there's a fit.
Our properties are in established neighborhoods and communities across the region.
We also own in Milwaukee, WI.
Selling a property, looking for a rental, a current resident, or a lender, broker or partner: one form reaches us, and we'll do our best to reply quickly.
Selling, renting, or simply reaching out, start with a text or a message. We'll do our best to reply quickly.